Reviewing Grid

Paper code

The paper code is available on the detailed form of the paper you are reviewing.

Main criteria

0 – Off topic / 3 – Insufficient compatibility / 6 – Average compatibility / – The paper can be taken into account / 10 – Excellent compatibility

0 – No innovation at all / 3 – Insufficient innovation / 6 – Relative innovation but the subject is interesting / 10 – Very innovative work

0 – Not transferable / 3 – Transferability to be demonstrated / 6 – Average transferability / 10 – Excellent transferability

0 – Not understandable / 3 – Understandable but poor arguments / 6 – Understandable and good arguments / 10 – The abstract is very clear with excellent arguments

Final choice


Thierry Maytraud Trophies

Stormwater integration in the project / The inclusion of the project in a sustainable development approach (environment, economy, society) / The governance and multi-partner approach of the project / The exemplarity of the project.


Poster - Starting research projects
Pedagogy session